Half a CloakWhat we actually know

Fact or legend?

One book, written by a friend.

Almost everything known about Martin comes from one writer, Sulpicius Severus, who knew him and admired him. Some of what is told about Martin is solid, some is disputed among historians, and some was added centuries later. This page sorts the best-known claims.

The trouble with the source

Sulpicius says he wrote what is true, and that he had it from Martin himself and from those who lived with him. But he wrote to praise, he shaped his scenes on biblical models, and he had a quarrel of his own with the bishops of Gaul. People doubted him in his lifetime. In his Dialogues one speaker reports that a man has accused Sulpicius of telling many lies in his book, and another begins to name living witnesses for each miracle because the listeners had doubts.

In 1912 the French historian E.-Ch. Babut argued that most of the Life was literary invention. Hippolyte Delehaye answered him at length in 1920. Later scholars such as Jacques Fontaine and Clare Stancliffe took a middle course: Sulpicius reports real people and real events, but he stylises them, and each story has to be weighed on its own.

Sixteen claims

  • In the book

    He cut his cloak in two for a beggar at Amiens

    Life, ch. 3. A hard winter, the city gate, a beggar everyone walks past. Martin has nothing left but his military cloak, cuts it down the middle with his sword and keeps half. Some bystanders laugh. Sulpicius is the only source and gives no year.

  • Not in the book

    He was on horseback

    The text mentions no horse. Martin did serve in a mounted unit, so it is not impossible, but the rider leaning down from the saddle comes from medieval art.

  • Painters’ choice

    The cloak was red

    Sulpicius gives no colour. Some writers argue that the guard cavalry wore white, which is a guess. Red is what most painters chose; others made it green, blue or violet.

  • Not in the book

    He gave only half because the other half belonged to the army

    A popular modern explanation with no ancient source. The reason Sulpicius gives is simpler: the cloak was all Martin had left, and he kept part so as not to be naked himself.

  • Disputed

    He was born in 316

    Both dates come from the sources. The figures of Gregory of Tours give 316. The Life’s own figures (enlisted at 15, baptised at 18, discharged about two years later under Julian) give about 336. Scholars are divided, so this site prints both.

  • Disputed

    He served five years in the army

    The Life says about five. If he was born in 316 and left under Julian, it was nearer twenty-five. Some historians think Sulpicius shortened it, because a long army career was an embarrassment for a bishop.

  • Only in the book

    The enemy surrendered the day after he refused to fight

    Life, ch. 4. No other source records this surrender, and the scene is hard to date.

  • Later legend

    Geese gave away his hiding place

    There are no geese in the Life. In chapter 9 a citizen of Tours pretends his wife is ill, Martin comes out to see her, and the crowd marches him to the city. The goose story appears much later, probably to explain why goose is eaten on his day.

  • Well established

    The word “chapel” comes from his cloak

    Medieval Latin cappella, “little cloak”, was the name of the relic, then of the royal oratory that held it, then of any small place of worship. Writers of the 9th century already explain it this way. A minority of scholars derive the word differently.

  • Solid from the 7th century

    The Frankish kings kept his cloak

    A royal judgment of about 680 records oaths sworn on the cappa of Saint Martin. Before that there are almost three centuries of silence: Sulpicius never says what became of Martin’s half, and nothing shows that Clovis owned it.

  • Almost certain

    He died on 8 November 397

    Sulpicius gives no date. The year comes from Gregory of Tours; the day is worked out from his “midnight on a Sunday” and from the burial feast of 11 November. A few writers, ancient and modern, put the death some years later.

  • Tours tradition

    The men of Tours took his body out through a window

    Not in Sulpicius. Gregory of Tours tells it nearly 200 years later, and the story serves his own city’s claim to the relics.

  • Hearsay

    Two thousand monks walked at his funeral

    The number is Sulpicius’s own, and he hedges it himself: they “are said” to have gathered. He was not there.

  • Legend

    Flowers bloomed along the Loire as his body passed

    Neither Sulpicius nor Gregory mentions flowers or warm weather. The story is later folklore explaining the mild days that often come around 11 November, “St Martin’s Summer”.

  • Too strong

    He was the first saint who was not a martyr

    Non-martyrs such as Antony of Egypt were already honoured in the East. Martin was among the first, and the most prominent in the Latin West, to receive a feast day and a pilgrimage shrine.

  • Solid

    His name means “of Mars”

    Martinus is an ordinary Roman name formed from Mars, the god of war. That his soldier father chose it on purpose is a reasonable guess and nothing more.

What is left

Take away the later legends and the doubtful numbers and a good deal remains. A soldier’s son from Pannonia left the army, lived as a monk near Poitiers and then near Tours, was made bishop against the wishes of other bishops, walked his diocese, argued with an emperor, and died at Candes in the last years of the fourth century.

And he did one thing with a cloak that nobody has been able to forget.

Keep reading

Martin in art →The man who said no →Patron of what? →After the book → Get the book, free

Sources: Sulpicius Severus, Life of Saint Martin, Letters and Dialogues; Gregory of Tours, History of the Franks I, 36 and 48. The positions of modern scholars (Babut, Delehaye, Fontaine, Stancliffe, Barnes) are summarised from reference works and reviews, not from the books themselves. Found a mistake? Tell us

Get the book